'Absolutely crazy' - R Ashwin slams India's decision to drop Mohammed Siraj and Ravindra Jadeja
R Ashwin questions India's decision to exclude Siraj and Ravindra Jadeja from the first Test against New Zealand at Wellington, arguing both players deserve the chance to fail on their own terms.
The first Test between India and New Zealand at Wellington on November 19 saw the Indian team management make selection decisions that drew immediate criticism from former off-spinner R Ashwin. The exclusion of two senior players, Mohammed Siraj and Ravindra Jadeja, sparked debate about the direction of India's Test selection strategy, particularly given their recent contributions to the team's overseas campaigns.
Siraj holds the position of India's leading wicket-taker in the current World Test Championship cycle, while Jadeja had accumulated 516 runs during India's previous Test tour of England. The selection committee instead opted for Akash Deep, Anshul Kamboj and Prasidh Krishna alongside Jasprit Bumrah, with Washington Sundar chosen as the spin-bowling all-rounder in place of Jadeja.
"This is a trend. When these things happen, we have to speak up. It is not about who is playing, when he is playing or where he comes from. But what happened today is something that will keep happening. And this is absolutely crazy!" Ashwin was quoted as saying by India Today.
The former India spinner elaborated on his concerns regarding the specific omissions and the broader implications for the team's composition. Jadeja's performance in England had been substantial, and Siraj had played a crucial role in India's efforts during that series when Bumrah was unavailable. Ashwin questioned why players with such proven track records were being sidelined.
"What is going on? Ravindra Jadeja scored 500 runs in the previous away series. He is now sitting out. Mohammed Siraj, in the absence of Jasprit Bumrah, helped India draw the England series. What does that tell you?" Ashwin added.
What is Ashwin's concern about India's bowling composition?
Ashwin also highlighted a pattern he had observed across India's recent cricket, noting that Siraj had been overlooked in the ODI series as well. He acknowledged that Prasidh Krishna was returning from injury and that Anshul Kamboj was gaining experience, but questioned the logic of repeatedly excluding players who had delivered for India in challenging overseas conditions.
"We had seen this trend during the ODI series as well. Siraj was not being picked. I thought perhaps they were keeping him fresh for the Test series. Prasidh Krishna is returning from injury. Anshul Kamboj has played only his second or third Test after featuring in England, and now he is playing again," India's ex-spinner noted.
Ashwin acknowledged that questions could be raised about individual players' form or fitness, but he maintained that both Siraj and Jadeja had earned the right to be judged on their own merits rather than being excluded preemptively. He stressed that their contributions to Indian cricket over many years warranted a different approach to their selection.
"Perhaps Siraj's pace has dropped. You can have an opinion on Ravindra Jadeja, but both these players have contributed so much to Indian cricket that they deserve a chance to fail on their own terms," Ashwin said.
Aakash Chopra questions Ravindra Jadeja omission in NZ Test
The bowling composition at Wellington also drew Ashwin's analytical attention. He pointed out that the match featured an unusually high concentration of right-arm seamers, which could create specific tactical challenges for India's bowling strategy across both innings. The presence of eight right-arm seamers in the match meant that most bowling would come from one end, potentially creating uneven wear on the pitch.
"Look at the number of right-arm seamers in this match. There are eight of them: Anshul Kamboj, Akash Deep, Prasidh Krishna, Jasprit Bumrah, Nathan Smith, Kyle Jamieson, Matt Henry and Jacob Duffy. Most of their overs will be from one end. That means a patch will develop on one side, and it could become rough for the left-handers as well when the second innings comes around." Ashwin said.
How does Ashwin view Siraj's role in overseas Test cricket?
In overseas Test cricket, spinners traditionally assume a more prominent wicket-taking role as matches progress into their later stages, when pitch deterioration becomes pronounced. Ashwin explained that by the fourth or fifth day, when rough patches and uneven surfaces develop, spinners become increasingly valuable. The absence of Jadeja meant India would lack that specialist option at a critical juncture.
"In overseas Test matches, spinners often play a wicket-taking role in the fourth innings, on the fourth or fifth day. By then, rough patches and potholes will have developed," Ashwin said.
Ashwin emphasised Siraj's particular value in overseas conditions, where his aggressive approach and ability to maintain pressure with an older ball could prove decisive. While he did not suggest that Siraj's inclusion would have guaranteed success, he argued that the pacer's mentality and proven ability to perform under pressure made him an asset India needed in Wellington.
"When nothing was happening with the old ball, India needed a bowler with the kind of attitude Mohammed Siraj brings. I am not saying that if Mohammed Siraj had played this game, he would have taken five wickets." Ashwin said.
Ashwin concluded by highlighting Siraj's consistency and willingness to engage fully in every match, qualities that had served India well across multiple overseas tours. Despite occasional lapses in control, Siraj had demonstrated his ability to contribute meaningfully to India's Test campaigns over several years.
"But you need someone in your attack who is free-spirited, who runs in and bowls every time. Yes, Siraj also leaks runs, but he manages to do something or the other. He has been doing that for so many years and has shown it," Ashwin said.
Download Our App
