'Will Siraj be an automatic pick? I don't know' - Murali Kartik's big statement on India's XI for 1st Test vs New Zealand
Former India spinner Murali Kartik has raised doubts about Mohammed Siraj's automatic selection in India's playing XI for the Wellington Test starting November 19, with six pace options in the squad.
The Shubman Gill-led India squad arrived in Wellington ahead of the first Test against New Zealand, scheduled from November 19 at the Basin Reserve, with the second Test to follow in Christchurch from November 27. The 16-member squad features six pace options, Jasprit Bumrah, Mohammed Siraj, Gurnoor Brar, Akash Deep, Prasidh Krishna and Anshul Kamboj, alongside spinners Ravindra Jadeja and Washington Sundar, raising genuine questions about which combination India will field in the opening match.
Former India spinner and ex-KKR player Murali Kartik expressed clear uncertainty over Siraj's place in the starting XI, pointing to the competition from Brar and the broader puzzle of building a bowling unit around Bumrah.
"With India, there will be some issues picking the playing XI. Is Siraj the No.1 bowler now? Not too long ago, in that 2-2 against England, he was the man. In Sri Lanka, he was not the man. Now, Gurnoor Brar is in the Test squad when Siraj was playing the ODIs, so what happens to that bowling unit? Who are the bowlers who are going to get picked with Jasprit Bumrah," Kartik questioned on Cricbuzz.
What did Kartik say about Siraj's selection and the spinner's dilemma?
Kartik's concerns extended beyond the pace department. He identified the spinner's slot as the central selection puzzle for India, given that New Zealand's batting lineup contains a significant number of left-handers. The choice between Washington Sundar and Ravindra Jadeja, both of whom also contribute as trusted lower-order batters, was flagged as the most difficult call for the team management to make.
"The question will be who is my spinner? That is the key bit. Who do I go for, because the opposition have lots of left-handers. Do I pick a Washington Sundar or would I go with Ravindra Jadeja, who is also a trusted batter. That is where my conundrum is right now. Bumrah picks himself, as does Prasidh Krishna. I will always pick Mohammed Siraj given these conditions and you want somebody running in when you feel disheartened. Will Siraj be an automatic pick? I don't know. Are they looking at Gurnoor Brar, looking at his success in white-ball cricket. For the love of God, I hope Siraj plays," Kartik elaborated.
Kartik's comments also touched on Nitish Kumar Reddy's potential role as a bowling all-rounder, adding another layer to India's selection deliberations. Rishabh Pant has already joined the squad's preparations in Wellington, giving the team management a full complement of players to assess before the Test begins.
How does Dinesh Karthik view India's pace combination for Wellington?
Former India wicketkeeper Dinesh Karthik offered a more structured view of the pace combination, suggesting that Bumrah and Siraj would form the first-choice pair and that the remaining spot would come down to a contest between Prasidh Krishna and Gurnoor Brar. Karthik also weighed in on the spin slot, seeing it as a straight choice between Washington Sundar and Nitish Kumar Reddy in the bowling all-rounder capacity.
"I believe India will have Bumrah and Siraj. The toss-up is between Prasidh and Gurnoor. I feel right now, it could be Gurnoor ahead of Prasidh. Jadeja for me is sure. It is only a question of Washington or Nitish Kumar Reddy in the bowling all-rounder slot. I do feel so in Test cricket, Siraj will be there, 100 percent," Karthik said, via the aforementioned source.
Kuldeep Yadav, who was part of the original squad, was released to play in the Syed Mushtaq Ali Trophy T20 domestic tournament, with Brar named as his replacement on November 14, 2026. Gurnoor Brar had made an impression during the ODI series against New Zealand, including a 22-run contribution in the fifth ODI that India won, further boosting his claims for a Test debut. Bumrah had not featured in a Test since November 2025, making his return to the side one of the more closely watched aspects of India's build-up to the Wellington match.
Download Our App
