Could today’s batters have survived against aggressive West Indies pacers?

The modern-day batters have a different starkly approach, mindset, and batting technique as compared to the past. How would they fare against the likes of Garner, Marshall, Roberts, Holding?

By Rathnam Nayak

Updated - 19 Jun 2025, 18:31 IST

2 Min Read

The likes of Joel Garner, Malcolm Marshall, Andy Roberts, Michael Holding and later Curtly Ambrose and Courtney Walsh made West Indies a pace menace in the 1970s and 80s. It was also the era when the Windies tasted the most success and conquered the cricket world. West Indies were one of the few sides which were renowned for their bowling more than batting at the time.

Cricket has become more batting-friendly in the current age. Larger bats, smaller ground dimensions, and flatter pitches have titled the game in favour of batters than bowlers. Amid of all of this, a compelling question is whether the current generation would have been able to face the ruthless pace attack of the previous generation.

One parameter which has seen the biggest shift is the manner in which pitches were prepared. In the older times, the pitches were would present considerable seam movement for the pacers. In sharp contrast to the 70s and 80s, pitches now are rolled thoroughly in order to eliminate any unpredictable behaviour.

Another point to take into consideration is the protective equipment, or rather, the lack of it. The gear during the earlier days was basic and provided minimal shielding. Chest and elbow pads were in their infancy while grills of helmets did not provide enough coverage. This used to play a role in the batters' psyche and the manner they approached batting.      

Coming to other themes, one which stands out is the mindset of the modern-day batters as compared to the past. Other than a few batters who don't mind batting out time and wearing down the bowlers, there is always an inclination towards quick run-scoring in the modern day. Bowlers of the past would not wear down as easily as the bowlers of the current age, given the significant increase in workload and cricketing action. This could serve as a vital point when it comes to taking the bowlers on.
There is an immense amount of data available with batters and the coaches which prepare them in the current day and age. This was not the case back in the day. Nowadays, batters are more aware of the strength of bowlers or their own weaknesses. The lack of such information and data made the sport more challenging in the past.
In a nutshell, the current crop of batters would have definitely needed a shift in mindset, mental toughness, and batting technique to face the past legends like Garner, Marshall, Roberts, Holding or Ambrose and Walsh.

Get every cricket updates! Follow Us:

Download Our App

For a better experience: Download the CricTracker app from the IOS and Google Play Store