'You've got to take the emotion out of it' - Shukri Conrad on Keshav Maharaj's omission
South Africa's head coach explains the difficult decision to leave out Keshav Maharaj, a decade-long stalwart, while the spinner prepares for an ODI captaincy role against Bangladesh.
4 Min Read
.jpeg)

Keshav Maharaj has been left out of South Africa's Test squad for the fourth consecutive match, marking the first time in a decade-long Test career that the left-arm spinner faces such an extended absence from the side. The omission comes as South Africa prepares for the Centurion Test against Bangladesh, which begins on Monday at SuperSport Park, a venue where teams sometimes operate without spinners in their playing eleven.
Maharaj was released from the Test squad during the Wanderers match against Bangladesh to return to domestic first-class cricket with the Dolphins, playing a four-day game in Durban that concludes on Sunday.
"Anybody would be disappointed, especially someone who's been a stalwart in the side for many a year. But Kesh being the ultimate pro that he is and ultimate team man, whilst the initial conversations were robust and I'd expect nothing else, he is fully understanding," Conrad said as quoted by Cricinfo.
"When I suggested that he go and play a first-class game for the Dolphins, he was all over that," he added.
The challenge of delivering such news to senior players remains one of the toughest aspects of Conrad's role. He explained the process of communicating difficult selection decisions to experienced cricketers. He noted that while the initial reaction is difficult, the path forward becomes clearer once the conversation concludes.
"There's no soft way of putting it. You basically sit a guy down and say 'you're left out and these are my reasons'. They'll get upset. It's often the toughest part of the job. But truth only hurts once. You tell them the truth and sketch a potential path back in," Conrad said.
How did Maharaj respond to the omission?
Conrad stressed the importance of removing emotion from selection decisions while acknowledging the human element involved in managing world-class players. He added that the manner in which difficult messages are delivered matters significantly.
"Lot of time you've got to take emotion out of it. But there is a human element. Sitting down with key players, experienced players, top-notch players, world-class players is the toughest part of the job. At the end of it, I think they respect you for the manner you deliver the message. They respect you for the fact you look them in the eye and sit down and chat. We all celebrate victories as hard as the guys that play," sadi Conrad.
Maharaj's immediate future in South African cricket extends beyond the Test arena, as he has been named stand-in ODI captain to lead the squad against Bangladesh next month in place of an injured Temba Bavuma. The spinner has led South Africa in one Test, seven ODIs and ten T20Is across his international career.
He has also captained two SA20 franchises, Durban's Super Giants and Pretoria Capitals, and his domestic team, the Dolphins. His appointment as ODI captain signals his continued importance to South Africa's plans heading toward the 2027 ODI World Cup, where quality spin is expected to play a significant role in home conditions.
Bavuma's injury management has become a recurring theme in South African cricket planning. Since his appointment as Test captain in February 2023, Bavuma has missed seven of South Africa's 25 Test matches through injury. His ODI captaincy, which began in April 2021, has seen him lead South Africa in 51 of 79 matches, with workload management and injury concerns frequently keeping him unavailable. Most notably, he sustained a hamstring injury at the 2023 ODI World Cup and played in the semi-final without being fully fit.
What is the challenge of dropping senior players?
South Africa currently occupies the top position in the 2025-2027 World Test Championship points table and holds a strong position to qualify for a second successive WTC final, which would take place in June if achieved. With the 2027-2031 Future Tours Programme yet to be released and no fixtures confirmed beyond April 2027, Conrad has already begun considering the broader picture for South Africa's leadership structure.
Aiden Markram serves as South Africa's T20I captain and has been the most regular stand-in for Bavuma, though Maharaj could potentially find himself in a position to lead at certain points in the lead-up to or during the 2027 World Cup.
"Depending on whether we get to a WTC final early, can we then use a Sri Lankan tour (in March) to possibly rest him? I don't know. There's a lot of permutations, a lot of things to think about. It's safe to say that Test cricket is the priority and we make sure that Temba gets through that," Conrad said.
Maharaj's domestic performance recently included a five-wicket haul of 5 for 62 against Western Province, where he claimed the first-ball dismissal of David Bedingham and had Kyle Verreynne caught for 13. These performances underscore his continued quality as a bowler and his readiness to compete for a Test recall.
For now, Maharaj remains outside South Africa's immediate Test plans, but his value to the team across formats and his leadership credentials ensure he remains very much in the picture over the medium term. The decision to leave him out, despite Harmer's recent success, has been difficult for everyone involved, particularly for the selector who had to deliver the message.
Download Our App